The Overuse of Chemicals in Water Treatment Facilities

Ever wonder about the journey your water takes before it reaches your glass? Drinking water undergoes a complex treatment process involving various chemicals to ensure its safety. This often-overlooked aspect of water treatment raises important questions about the potential overuse of chemicals and its impact on public health and the environment.

The Water Treatment Process

The water treatment process involves several steps to ensure that the water supplied to homes and businesses is safe to drink. The first step is collection, where water is gathered from natural sources such as rivers, lakes, reservoirs, or underground aquifers. This raw water often contains various impurities, including dirt, organic matter, and microorganisms, which need to be removed to make the water safe for consumption.

Once collected, the water undergoes coagulation and flocculation. During coagulation, chemicals are added to the water to neutralize the charge of small particles suspended in the water, causing them to clump together into larger particles, or flocs. This process is crucial because it transforms tiny, hard-to-remove particles into larger aggregates that can be more easily separated from the water.

The next step is sedimentation, where the water is allowed to sit undisturbed in large tanks. During this period, the heavy flocs formed during coagulation and flocculation gradually settle to the bottom of the tank due to gravity. This sedimentation process significantly reduces the turbidity of the water, as many of the suspended solids are removed at this stage.

Following sedimentation, the water undergoes filtration. In this step, the water passes through various filters, typically composed of sand, gravel, and charcoal. These filters are designed to capture and remove any remaining particles, bacteria, and other contaminants that were not removed during sedimentation. Filtration is a vital step as it further purifies the water, ensuring that it is clear and free from harmful microorganisms.

The disinfection stage comes next, which is perhaps one of the most critical steps in the water treatment process. Disinfectants such as chlorine, chloramine, or ozone are used to kill any remaining bacteria, viruses, and other pathogens. Different disinfectants have their own advantages and limitations, and the choice of disinfectant can depend on various factors, including the quality of the raw water and the infrastructure of the water treatment facility.

Finally, the treated water is moved to storage and distribution. From these storage tanks, the water is distributed through an extensive network of pipes to homes, businesses, and other facilities. This stage ensures that clean, safe water is readily available to the public whenever it is needed. Proper storage and distribution are crucial to prevent recontamination of the treated water and to maintain the quality achieved through the preceding treatment processes [1].

*Source: https://www.cdc.gov/healthywater/drinking/public/water_treatment.html*

The Role of Chemicals in Water Treatment

The water treatment process relies on a variety of chemicals to ensure that the water is safe for consumption.

Coagulants

Aluminum sulfate (alum) is one of the most commonly used coagulants in water treatment. Alum works by binding small particles, such as dirt, organic matter, and other suspended solids, into larger clumps called flocs. These larger particles are easier to settle and remove from the water, significantly improving clarity and reducing turbidity.

Ferric chloride is another common coagulant often used in both water and wastewater treatment. Similar to alum, it helps in forming flocs by neutralizing the charges of suspended particles. Ferric chloride is particularly useful in situations where the water contains a high level of organic matter, as it can enhance the removal of these contaminants during sedimentation and filtration [2].

Disinfectants

Chlorine is widely used in water treatment facilities due to its effectiveness in killing bacteria, viruses, and other pathogens. However, chlorine must be carefully managed because it can form harmful byproducts, such as trihalomethanes (THMs), when it reacts with organic matter in the water. Proper dosing and monitoring are essential to minimize these byproducts while maintaining effective disinfection.

Chloramine is a combination of chlorine and ammonia. It is used for longer-lasting disinfection in the water distribution system, as it remains active in the water for a longer period compared to chlorine alone. Chloramine is particularly useful for preventing microbial regrowth in the distribution pipes, ensuring that the water remains safe as it travels to consumers [1].

Ozone is a powerful oxidizing agent and an effective disinfectant that does not leave harmful residues in the water. It can quickly inactivate a wide range of pathogens, including bacteria, viruses, and protozoa. However, ozone requires careful handling and specialized equipment, making it more expensive and complex to implement compared to chlorine or chloramine [3].

pH Adjusters

Lime (calcium hydroxide) is used to raise the pH of water, making it less acidic. This adjustment is crucial for protecting pipes and infrastructure from corrosion, which can lead to the leaching of metals like lead and copper into the water supply. By stabilizing the pH, lime helps to ensure that the water remains safe and does not cause damage to plumbing systems.

Sodium hydroxide is particularly effective in treating highly acidic water. It helps to neutralize the acidity, bringing the pH to a more neutral level that is safer for consumption and less corrosive to pipes and equipment [4].

Corrosion Inhibitors

Phosphates are used to form a protective coating inside pipes, reducing the risk of corrosion and the subsequent leaching of metals such as lead and copper. Phosphates are particularly important in older water systems where pipe materials may be prone to corrosion. By creating a barrier between the water and the pipe material, phosphates help to ensure the long-term integrity of the distribution system and the safety of the water.

Silicates also work by forming a protective layer on the inside of pipes, helping to prevent metal leaching and maintaining water quality. Silicates are often used in combination with other corrosion inhibitors to enhance their effectiveness [5].

Fluoridation Agents

Fluorosilicic acid is added to water to help prevent dental cavities. The practice of fluoridation has been endorsed by many health organizations worldwide due to its proven benefits in reducing the prevalence of tooth decay. Fluorosilicic acid must be carefully dosed to ensure that the fluoride levels in drinking water are safe and effective for dental health without posing a risk to consumers [6].

Concerns About the Overuse of Chemicals

Health Risks

The overuse of chemicals in water treatment can potentially pose health risks. While these chemicals are essential for ensuring safe drinking water, their excessive use can lead to adverse health effects. For instance, high levels of disinfectants like chlorine can form harmful byproducts such as trihalomethanes (THMs) and haloacetic acids (HAAs). These byproducts are formed when chlorine reacts with organic matter present in the water. Prolonged exposure to THMs and HAAs has been linked to an increased risk of cancer, particularly bladder cancer, as well as liver and kidney damage. Furthermore, these compounds can cause reproductive issues and developmental problems in fetuses and infants [7].

Similarly, overexposure to aluminum sulfate (alum), used as a coagulant, has raised concerns about potential links to neurological disorders, including Alzheimer’s disease. Although the evidence is not conclusive, studies suggest that high levels of aluminum in drinking water might contribute to the accumulation of neurotoxic aluminum compounds in the brain, potentially accelerating the development of neurodegenerative diseases. Other health issues associated with aluminum exposure include bone diseases and dialysis encephalopathy in patients with kidney problems [8].

Furthermore, excessive fluoridation can lead to dental fluorosis, a condition that causes discoloration and damage to teeth. Fluoridation is intended to reduce the incidence of dental cavities, but when fluoride levels exceed recommended limits, it can lead to mottling and pitting of the teeth, especially in children whose teeth are still developing. In severe cases, skeletal fluorosis can occur, causing pain and damage to bones and joints [9].

Environmental Impact

The environmental impact of overusing chemicals in water treatment is also a significant concern. Chemical runoff from treatment plants can enter natural water bodies, leading to detrimental effects on aquatic life and overall ecosystem health. High concentrations of chlorine and chloramine can be particularly toxic to fish and other aquatic organisms. These chemicals, when released into natural water systems, can disrupt essential biological processes, such as respiration and reproduction, leading to reduced biodiversity and the collapse of local fish populations [10].

For instance, chlorine and chloramine can interfere with the oxygen-carrying capacity of fish gills, causing respiratory stress and, in severe cases, death. These disinfectants can also react with natural organic matter in water bodies to form chlorinated byproducts, which may be even more toxic than the original compounds. The presence of these chemicals can also alter the behavior and physiology of aquatic organisms, affecting their growth, development, and survival rates. Moreover, the disruption of microbial communities in aquatic ecosystems can impair nutrient cycling and degrade water quality, further impacting plant and animal life [11].

Bioaccumulation is another critical environmental issue associated with the overuse of water treatment chemicals. Certain chemicals, such as phosphates used as corrosion inhibitors, can accumulate in the environment over time. Phosphates, for example, are nutrients that can lead to eutrophication when they enter water bodies in excessive amounts. This nutrient pollution promotes the growth of algae, resulting in algal blooms that deplete oxygen levels in the water through a process called hypoxia. As the algae die and decompose, they consume large amounts of oxygen, creating "dead zones" where most aquatic life cannot survive. These hypoxic conditions can lead to massive fish kills and the loss of biodiversity in affected areas [12].

Additionally, the persistent presence of some treatment chemicals in the environment can lead to long-term ecological changes and disrupt natural processes. For instance, chemicals such as aluminum sulfate can alter the pH of water bodies, making them more acidic and affecting the organisms that live there. Acidification can reduce the availability of essential nutrients for aquatic plants and increase the solubility of toxic metals, which can be harmful to both plants and animals. Over time, these changes can lead to shifts in species composition and ecosystem structure, potentially resulting in the loss of sensitive species and the proliferation of more tolerant but less desirable ones [13].

Furthermore, the continuous release of water treatment chemicals can have cascading effects throughout the food web. For example, if a chemical accumulates in small aquatic organisms, it can be passed up the food chain to larger predators, including fish, birds, and mammals. This biomagnification can lead to higher concentrations of the chemical in top predators, potentially causing reproductive failures, behavioral changes, and even mortality. The long-term exposure of wildlife to these chemicals can also lead to chronic health issues, weakening populations and reducing their ability to adapt to other environmental stressors.

Reducing Chemical Overuse

Optimizing chemical dosage is crucial to minimizing the overuse of chemicals in water treatment. The use of real-time monitoring and automation can significantly enhance the efficiency and precision of chemical dosing. Real-time monitoring involves the continuous measurement of water quality parameters such as pH, turbidity, and residual chlorine levels. These measurements provide immediate feedback on the effectiveness of the treatment process, allowing for rapid adjustments to chemical dosages. For example, online sensors can detect changes in water quality and automatically adjust the dosage of coagulants or disinfectants to maintain optimal levels.

Automation systems integrate real-time monitoring data with advanced control algorithms to optimize chemical dosing. These systems can automatically adjust chemical feed rates based on water quality data, reducing the likelihood of over- or under-dosing. Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) systems are commonly used in modern water treatment plants to monitor and control treatment processes. SCADA systems can analyze trends, predict changes in water quality, and make real-time adjustments to chemical dosages, ensuring consistent treatment performance while minimizing chemical use.

About Kraken Sense

Kraken Sense develops all-in-one pathogen and chemical detection solutions to accelerate time to results by replacing lab testing with a single field-deployable device. Our proprietary device, the KRAKEN, detects bacteria and viruses down to 1 copy and can be integrated with SCADA systems. It has already been applied for epidemiology detection in wastewater and microbial contamination testing in food processing, among many other applications. Our team of highly-skilled Microbiologists and Engineers tailor the system to fit individual project needs. To stay updated with our latest articles and product launches, follow us on LinkedIn, Twitter, and Instagram, or sign up for our email newsletter. Discover the potential of continuous, autonomous pathogen testing by speaking to our team.